The main power sources available in space are solar PV and various forms of nuclear power: radioisotope decay, fission, and perhaps eventually fusion.
Current and near future satellites and probes get their power as follows.
Source | Purpose | Details | Power Range |
---|---|---|---|
Solar | Most satellites | 3-junction cells, 30% efficiency | Few watts to 10s of kW |
Radioisotope | Outer solar system, planetary landers | Pu-238, Am-241, Po-210 | 100 W to 100 kW |
Fission | Large robotic missions, crewed Mars mission | Various designs | 45.5 kW to 2 MW (thermal) and 650 W to 100 kW (electric) |
Active areas of research include higher efficiency, 4- to 6- junction solar cells 1, new small fission reactors such as NASA's Kilopower project 2, and reverse field configuration fusion 4.
The use of radioisotope thermal generators (RTG) or nuclear fission in space entails launching radioactive material from Earth, which raises safety concerns. Results have been found as follows.
Study | Results |
---|---|
Mars 2020 Environmental Impact Statement 5 | Maximally exposed person would have less than 1/1,000,000 chance of death. |
Analysis of Ulysses Mission 6 | Expected 3 cancer deaths if there is an accident after launch. |
General Review 7 | RTG launch is generally safe. |
Under international regulations, a fission reactor such as NASA's Kilopower could not be activated until it safely escapes Earth. However, there are scenarios under which a reactor could become critical in a launch failure 8, and therefore rules are needed to govern the launch of reactors that go beyond what has been learned with RTGs 9, 10.
KiloPower uses highly-enriched uranium (HEU) as its fuel. A reactor that uses low-enriched uranium (LEU) instead would have greater mass, increasing launch costs, but might save money overall because LEU would have lower security costs than HEU 11.
Nuclear thermal rockets (NTR) have greater exhaust velocity than chemical rockets 12 but low impulse 13. This, together with the safety and regulatory issues around operating fission reactors in the atmosphere, might make them suitable for propulsuion but not for launch. In that case we imagine an NTR would have safety issues comparable to launching a fission reactor. Nuclear pulse propulsion, such as by Project Orion, entails the use of nuclear explosions for propulsion and is not permitted under the Partial Test Ban Treaty, even in space 14.
European Space Agency. "Power Systems". Accessed November 10, 2019. ↩ ↩2
Gibson, M., Oleson, S., Poston, D., McClure, P. "NASA’s Kilopower Reactor Development and the Path to Higher Power Missions". National Aeronautics and Space Administration. ↩ ↩2
World Nuclear Association. "Nuclear Reactors and Radioisotopes for Space". Accessed November 10, 2019. ↩
Thomas, S., Paluszek, M., Cohen, S. "Fusion-Enabled Pluto Orbiter and Lander". Phase 1 Final Report, NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts grant. April 2017. ↩
NASA. "Environmental Impact Statement, Mars 2020 Mission". March 2020. ↩
Goldman, M., Nelson, R. C., Bollinger, L., Hoover, M. D., Templeton, W., Anspaugh, L. "Potential Health Risks from Postulated Accidents Involving the Pu-238 RTG on the Ulysses Solar Exploration Mission". Presented at the 8th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power Systems, Albuquerque. November 1990. ↩
Bennett, G. L. "Safety Status of Space Radioisotope and Reactor Power Sources". Proceedings of the 25th Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference, Reno, NV. August 1990. ↩
McClure, P. R. "Kilopower Space Reactor Launch Safety - Maximum Credible Dose for a Criticality Accident". Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA); USDOE. September 2018. ↩
Behrens, J., Bueconsejo, R., Lal, B., Howieson, S. "Developing a Launch Approval Process for Nuclear Fission Reactors: Lessons Learned from Risk Mitigation and Approval Processes in Other Sectors". ANS NETS 2018 – Nuclear and Emerging Technologies for Space, Las Vegas, NV. February-March 2018. ↩
Camp, A., Klein, A., McCallum, P., Voss, S. "Potential Improvements to the Nuclear Safety and Launch Approval Process for Nuclear Reactors Utilized for Space Power and Propulsion Applications: A Report to the Nuclear Power & Propulsion Technical Discipline Team". NASA/TM-2019-220256. February 2019. ↩
Voss, S. S., Camp, A. "Considerations for Launching a Nuclear Fission Reactor for Space-based Missions". In AIAA SPACE and Astronautics Forum and Exposition. 2017. ↩
Pettit, D. "The Tyranny of the Rocket Equation". National Aeronautics and Space Administration. May 2012. ↩
Nam, S. H., Venneri, P., Kim, Y., Lee, J. I., Chang, S. H., Jeong, Y. H. "Innovative concept for an ultra-small nuclear thermal rocket utilizing a new moderated reactor". Nuclear Engineering and Technology 47(6), pp. 678-699. October 2015. ↩
Caselli, L. P. "Space Demilitarization Treaties in a New Era of Manned Nuclear Spaceflights". Journal of Air Law and Commerce 77(3): 7, pp. 641-669. 2012. ↩